Casey Anthony never publicly revealed the father of her murdered daughter, Caylee Anthony — but The National ENQUIRER can! The ENQUIRER has learned a Massachusetts woman believes her late son fathered the tragic toddler! Monster mom Casey gave birth to Caylee in August 2005, but she never revealed the name of Caylee’s father to many of the people she was once closest to, including her parents, George and Cindy Anthony. Former friends have described Casey — who was acquitted of murdering Caylee — as a “pathological liar” and claimed she may not even know who fathered Caylee! Other former friends and roommates remembered one hint that the Florida party girl dropped about her mystery baby daddy: Casey claimed he died in a car accident! Read on for details of our investigation, and click here for more true crime news….
1 of 8
Photo credit: Mega
That clue led Donna Maclean to name her son, Michael Duggan, who lost his life in a car accident in 2007, as Caylee’s father! According to Donna, her son was living in Winter Park, Fla. when he met Casey, shown here recently on a date in a Sunshine State bar.
2 of 8
Photo credit: NatENQ Files
When Donna began watching TV coverage of Casey’s murder trial and saw Caylee’s face, she realized her son was likely Caylee’s father. “I was Google searching and I read that [Caylee’s father] died out of state in 2007. I thought, that’s when Mike died,” Donna told The ENQUIRER.
3 of 8
Photo credit: Getty Images
Caylee’s round face and smile bore a striking resemblance to her son’s, according to Donna. She also claimed she once received a phone call from her son with caller ID that read, “George Anthony.”
4 of 8
Photo credit: Getty Images
“I’m looking at the trial on television and I could hear Mike saying, ‘Casey, Caylee, George, Cindy,’ ” Donna told The ENQUIRER. “That’s when it all dawned on me. I thought, Oh, my God, that’s my granddaughter!”
5 of 8
Photo credit: Getty Images
Caylee’s maternal grandmother, Cindy, reported the two-year-old missing in a 911 call on July 15, 2008, saying she hadn’t seen the tot for 31 days. In the call, a panicked Cindy wailed: “There is something wrong. I found my daughter’s car today and it smells like there’s been a dead body in the damn car.”
6 of 8
Photo credit: Getty Images
7 of 8
Photo credit: Getty Images
After a trial in 2011, a jury found Casey not guilty of first-degree murder, but guilty of four misdemeanor counts of providing false information to a law-enforcement officer. Meanwhile, the woman who believes Caylee was her granddaughter is nursing a broken heart.
8 of 8
Photo credit: Getty Images
“I’ve lived for years believing my son Michael was Caylee’s father,” Donna told The ENQUIRER. “I’ve never stopped believing it.
I wish I could move on, but I don’t have closure.”
That clue led Donna Maclean to name her son, Michael Duggan, who lost his life in a car accident in 2007, as Caylee’s father! According to Donna, her son was living in Winter Park, Fla. when he met Casey, shown here recently on a date in a Sunshine State bar.
When Donna began watching TV coverage of Casey’s murder trial and saw Caylee’s face, she realized her son was likely Caylee’s father. “I was Google searching and I read that [Caylee’s father] died out of state in 2007. I thought, that’s when Mike died,” Donna told The ENQUIRER.
Photo credit: NatENQ Files
Caylee’s round face and smile bore a striking resemblance to her son’s, according to Donna. She also claimed she once received a phone call from her son with caller ID that read, “George Anthony.”
Photo credit: Getty Images
“I’m looking at the trial on television and I could hear Mike saying, ‘Casey, Caylee, George, Cindy,’ ” Donna told The ENQUIRER. “That’s when it all dawned on me. I thought, Oh, my God, that’s my granddaughter!”
Photo credit: Getty Images
Caylee’s maternal grandmother, Cindy, reported the two-year-old missing in a 911 call on July 15, 2008, saying she hadn’t seen the tot for 31 days. In the call, a panicked Cindy wailed: “There is something wrong. I found my daughter’s car today and it smells like there’s been a dead body in the damn car.”
Photo credit: Getty Images
Photo credit: Getty Images
After a trial in 2011, a jury found Casey not guilty of first-degree murder, but guilty of four misdemeanor counts of providing false information to a law-enforcement officer. Meanwhile, the woman who believes Caylee was her granddaughter is nursing a broken heart.
Photo credit: Getty Images
“I’ve lived for years believing my son Michael was Caylee’s father,” Donna told The ENQUIRER. “I’ve never stopped believing it.
I wish I could move on, but I don’t have closure.”
Photo credit: Getty Images
