Hurt Locker hunk Jeremy Renner is Hollywood’s hottest new leading man — but the Oscar-nominated actor is embroiled in a gay mystery!

“I have never had the pleasure of meeting Jeremy’s boyfriend, but the fact that Jeremy is gay has never been a primary concern,” Melanee Wyatt, an early acting coach of Jeremy’s, recently told a reporter.

But is he or isn’t he? Jeremy isn’t saying.

One the one hand, his close pals say that he’s a sensitive mama’s boy who prefers makeup to guns and is dying to star in a musical!

On the other: He’s been seen out lately with one of the most beautiful women in Hollywood, Charlize Theron.

Pick up the new issue of The ENQUIRER to read more on Jeremy and why a longtime confidant calls him "a contradiction."