American Idol winner Carrie Underwood was caught in a love triangle with two fellow finalists -- after dumping her hometown sweetheart.

Blonde Carrie captured the nation's heart by winning the hugely popular TV star search. But the 22- year-old farm girl from Oklahoma also won the hearts of rivals Bo Bice and Anthony Fedorov.

And she left student boyfriend Drake Clark "devastated" after breaking up with him in the middle of the competition.

- Read all about Underwood and the men in her life in this week's Enquirer.